Water Fluoridation
Researched and
written by Michelle
Wolhuter RCST
I found out about the intent of the South
African government to add fluoride to the drinking water by reading a local
newspaper article. This spurred me on to
do some research, the findings of which are summarized below. This information is worth knowing – no matter
where you live on this planet. There is
a tremendous amount of information available on fluoride and its side effects –
this just touches the tip of the ice-burg.
Fluorine
is a highly reactive element which likes to bond with other elements – fluorine
added to water has commonly become known as fluoride. Fluoride occurs naturally in water in certain
areas of the world, most often in volcanic environments e.g.
When water is artificially fluoridated
sodium fluoride (NaF), sodium silicofluoride or hydrofluosilic acid is
added. These types of fluorides are
waste products, which come from various industries, such as the aluminium and phosphate
fertilizer industry. They are incredibly
toxic – more poisonous than lead and only slightly less poisonous than arsenic
(Clin Toxicol Commerc Prod, 1984;
11:4,112, 129, 138). They have
been used as pesticides, and are a component in fungicides, rodenticides,
anaesthetics and many drugs. They are also used in toothpaste, mouth
rinses and dental gels. In animal
studies it has been shown that the lethal dose of sodium fluoride is
approximately 50 times smaller than naturally occurring fluoride.
The 1920’s
and ‘30s saw the astronomical growth of the aluminum and phosphate fertilizer
industries. Their rapid growth gave rise
to unexpected pollution problems. The
pollutant – fluoride. Getting rid of this waste product caused an international
dumping problem, similar to that of atomic waste. One means of profitable
disposing of fluoride was to sell it as a rat poison and insecticide. It also got put into the public drinking
water in certain countries (and still is to this day).
The
government and the dental profession in certain countries have convinced the
public that fluoridated water offers nothing but benefits – they say that there
is overwhelming evidence that it prevents tooth decay and contributes to the
strength of bones.
Does
Fluoride Prevent Cavities?
In a word
– no. Studies from
In fluoridated areas, high percentages of
the population suffer from dental fluorosis, where teeth are mottled from high
deposits of fluoride. In Birmingham
(United Kingdom), where water has been fluoridated at 1 ppm since 1964, more
that a third of children suffer from dental fluorosis (Health & Homeopathy,
Spring, 1998: 24 –5).
Effects on
the teeth first manifest themselves as pitting and cavities on the surface of
the tooth enamel due to demineralisation, at levels of fluoride as low as
0.5mg/l or 0.5 ppm.
(Extracts from What Doctors Don’t Tell you –
March 1999)
There are many studies done which prove that
adding fluoride to the drinking water has absolutely nothing to do with
preventing tooth decay – see website listings at the end of this article should
you wish to do further research in this regard.
In South Africa the Minister of Health,
Manto Tshabalala-Msimang, indicated that water service providers are obliged to
fluoridate the water to a concentration level of up to 0.7mg/l (Roodepoort Record Newspaper – October, 3,
2003)
Let’s go back to the beginning
In 1938, Dr Gerald Cox of the Mellon
Institute (the Mellons were owners of the Aluminum Company of
The
Plot Thickens – let’s dig a little deeper
During the darkest days of World War II,
hundreds of thousands of innocent people were exterminated in German and
Russian concentration camps. Death from disease, starvation and extreme
brutality was an everyday occurrence, and this was regularly compounded by the
use of drugs and chemicals. Nazi scientists,
keen to maintain a climate of fear, had found an easy method of controlling the
behavior of camp inmates. Repeated doses
of very small amounts of fluoride were discovered to affect the brain, slowly
poisoning and narcotizing people, making them submissive. Eager to exploit the effects of the drug,
both German and Russian camp commanders added fluoride to water supplies.
The effects of fluoridated water greatly
impressed German and Russian intelligence.
They considered fluoridated water the ideal means of controlling Allied
populations once their countries had been invaded by German forces. Anticipating victory in the war, the German
chemical manufacturers L.G. Farben, based in
At the end of World War II, the
I.G. Farben expanded massively in the 1920’s
as it merged with the Wall Street concerns of the likes of Henry Ford’s motor
company, J.P. Morgan’s General Motors and Standard Oil, owned by the
Rockefeller family. Millions of US
dollars were invested in these concerns in the 1930s, and this relationship
continued throughout WW II.
Coincidentally, it is interesting to note that no I.G. Farben factories or plants were bombed, sabotaged or even
damaged by the Allies during the war.
It is also known that a number of influential figures in
·
Around 5.5 million people drink
artificially fluoridated water in the
·
According to fluoride researcher Ian
E. Stephens, Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher tripled the water-fluoridation
budget in
·
Over 60 tranquilizers on the market
contain fluoride, which profoundly increases the potency of other
substances. Fluoridating the ubiquitous
tranquilizer Diazepam (Valium) produces a new, stronger tranquilizer,
Rohypnol. Both are manufactured by Roche
Products, another subsidiary of I.G. Farben, along with other similar drugs. The powerful fluoridated tranquilizer
Stelazine is widely used in retirement homes and mental institutions around the
world. The US FDA estimates of Prozac
related suicides is 188 000 and deaths 175 000.
Prozac is a fluoride compound.
What
effect does fluoride have on the body?
Fluoride
brittles and structurally effects bones: At the recommended level (1ppm), fluoride
thins and brittles the bones (fluorosis) and it doubles the number of hip
fractures in older men and women in fluoridated communities. Increases in hip fractures are found at even
1/10th the recommended level.
There is much published evidence
that it causes osteoporosis at very low levels. It has a devastating effect on skeletal
development in babies and children.
Dental
fluorosis: a
defect in the formation of tooth enamel in children which results in mottled
teeth. This is not reversible and
remains for life.
Soft
tissue damage: The
late
It has a strong affinity to calcium, but
will also readily combine with magnesium and manganese ions and so can
interfere with many enzyme systems that require these minerals. The
interruption of these enzyme systems, in turn, disturbs carbohydrate
metabolism, bone formation and muscle function. Indeed, every vital function in the body
depends on enzymes; because fluoride
easily reaches every organ, many diverse toxic symptoms can result.
The blood enzyme cholinesterase is inhibited
by 61% on exposure to 0.95 ppm fluoride – an amount within recommended levels –
adversely affecting functions of the
nervous system
It’s also been shown by research at Kings
College in London that fluoride forms very strong hydrogen bonds with amides,
which are formed when amino acids join together to form a protein. This
can cause chromosomal damage. If the
protein is distorted, the body’s immune system no longer recognises it, treats
it as a foreign protein and will try to destroy it, which in turn triggers allergic skin or gastrointestinal reactions.
Stomach
and bowel disorders are the main features of fluoride
intolerance. Even small amounts of
fluoride can form hydrofluoric acid in the stomach to produce gastric pains,
nausea and vomiting. Young children are
particularly at risk.
Links
with thyroid disease:
the most readily identifiable feature of soft-tissue fluorosis is
extraordinary general fatigue, which is frequently linked to thyroid
deficiency. The thyroid gland requires
iodine to produce the hormone thyroxine, which controls the rate of metabolism
in the body. But when fluorine is
present, iodine is displaced, which will cause the thyroid gland to stop
working properly (K Roholdm Handbuch Experimenteller Pharma-kologie,
Ergaenzungswerk, Vol 7, Berlin:Springer, 1938:20).
The parathyroid gland, which regulates the
distribution of calcium and phosphorus in the body, is extremely sensitive to
excessive amounts of fluoride. Over 50
years ago, Indian doctors found a close relationship between skeletal fluorosis
and hyperparathyroidism.
Professor A K Susheela of the Fluoride and
Fluorosis Research Foundation of India has published over 100 scientific papers
on the hazards of fluoride. She has
proved that when exposed to fluoride, red blood cells are killed prematurely, lowering haemoglobin and causing anaemia. She also showed that calcium levels diminish
as fluoride levels in the body rise; the
gastrointestinal tract mucosa is damaged, causing irritable bowl syndrome, and blood fluoride levels rise continuously
with prolonged use of fluoridated toothpaste.
When people are bombarded with fluoride, in the form of fluoridated
water, toothpaste and mouth rinses, muscles and elements of connective tissue,
particularly collagen fiber and bone tissue undergo degenerative changes.
The
heart and blood vessels are affected by fluoride. In 1950, five years after experimental
introduction of fluoride into drinking water in
Fluoride
affects the brain and entire central nervous system. Neurological problems like headaches,
vertigo, spasticity in extremities, visual disturbances and impaired mental
acuity can all result. Tissue damage to
anterior horn cells (cells in the forward-facing section of the spinal cord)
has been found (Fluoride, 1975; 8: 61-85).
Official annual statistics revealed that
among malnourished children in the
Chilean town of
Fluoride
and Fertility: Abnormal sperm cells which have been damaged
by fluoride, can give rise to birth
defects. Vitamin E is the sex
vitamin as it improves fertility and virility .
Vitamin E and other antioxidants protect the body against reactive
oxidants which damage the DNA of tissue cells causing genetic changes and
cancer. Fluoride destroys Vit E, and is one of the reasons why 10 – 20
million American men are losing their virility and becoming sterile – they
produce less sperm and it is of poor quality.
The Medical Research Council in
(Extract from a paper by Dr Frank Bertrand,
B.D.S. Dunelm)
Fluoride,
Hyperactivity and Violence: Fluoride ingestion by children is extremely
hazardous to biological development and lifespan. Apart from having a devastating effect on
bone growth and immune function (remember a child’s immune and nervous system
is forming), fluoride affects a child’s
learning capabilities. Prof. Carlson
(pharmacology –
At a 1998 conference on fluoride in
Could fluoride be an undisclosed
contributing factor to the ‘epidemic’ of ADD, ADHD and hyperactivity in our
children at this time?
Nature holds up huge warning signs
·
Nature is very sparing with fluoride
·
Even in fluoridated areas the
lactating mother’s system filters out the fluoride before it gets into the breastmilk. Mother’s milk contains only 0.01 – 0.05 ppm
fluoride, a level of fluoride below what is found in any other food. This is nature’s way of protecting the small
child from fluoride damage.
·
Bottle-fed babies whose formula
(which often contains fluoride) is made up with fluoridated water will get
between 4 and 20 times as much fluoride as is contained in breastmilk, and at
any rate more than the maximum dosage which is considered safe.
Fluorosilic
acid increases the leaching of aluminium from cookware. Aluminium is considered one of the principal
causes of Alzheimer’s disease. It is not just a coincidence that Alzheimer’s
and other diseases became prominent at the same time as the introduction of
fluoride to the drinking waters of municipalities throughout the world.
Shortly after the introduction of fluoride
into drinking water systems, a team funded by the Medical Research Council in
Fluoride
and the Immune System:
The immune system is the body’s major defense mechanism against
disease. White blood cells serve as the
body’s surveillance system, recognizing and destroying foreign agents such as
bacteria, viruses, chemicals as well as the body’s own obsolete, damaged, or
cancerous cells.
In order for white blood cells to get to the
agent that they must destroy, they must first be passively carried to the
general area through the bloodstream. At
that point, they must squeeze through the walls of blood vessels and literally
“creep” through to the location of the agent to be destroyed.
Dr Sheila Gibson from the
Fluoride Concentration
|
Exposure
Time |
Relative
Migration Rate |
|
0 ppm |
6 hours |
100% |
|
0.1 ppm |
6 hours |
79% |
|
0.5 ppm |
6 hours |
26% |
|
1 ppm |
6 hours |
15% |
|
2 ppm |
6 hours |
0 % |
The fact that as little as 0.1 part per
million fluoride retarded white cell migration to a substantial degree
indicates that there may be no safe level of fluoride.
The destruction of bacteria and other
foreign agents by white cells is called phagocytosis. Fluoride depletes the energy reserves and the
ability of white blood cells to properly destroy foreign agents by
phagocytosis. Even micomolar amounts of
fluoride, i.e. below 1 part per million, may seriously depress the ability of
white blood cells to destroy pathogenic agents.
Fluoride confuses the immune system and
causes it to attack the body’s own tissues (called an autoimmune
response). In such cases, the clinical
observations of skin rashes, gastrointestinal disorders, lupus, rheumatoid
arthritis etc. are to be expected.
Fluoride slows down and weakens those very cells which serve as the
body’s defense system and thus allows foreign agents such as bacteria, viruses,
and chemicals as well as the body’s own damaged, or cancerous cells to wreak
havoc throughout the body. Otherwise
minor infections, now fighting an immune system weakened by fluoride, take
longer to throw off and more serious illnesses result. Cancer cells which might otherwise be
contained or destroyed end up taking the life of the victim.
This fluoride-induced weakening of the
immune system explains the results of Drs. Alfred Taylor and Nell Taylor of the
Genetic
Damage and Cancer:
The ability of fluoride to cause genetic damage is so well recognized
that investigators are now trying to find ways to counteract its genetic
damaging effects.
Substances like fluoride which cause genetic
damage are called mutagenic substances and it is a well-accepted fact that
substances which are mutagenic also tend to be carcinogenic, or cancer
producing. In fact, this is exactly what
has been found with regard to fluoride.
Dr Takeki Tsutsui and co-workers of the
Dr Wolfgang Klein and co-workers at the
From a
careful examination of the work of Drs Burk (U.S. National Cancer Institute)
and Yiamouyiannis, the best indication is that fluoride exposure from
fluoridation alone results in a 5 – 10% increase in cancer death rate. This means that 10 000 to 20 000 people in
the United States die of cancer each year due to fluoridation of public
drinking waters. (Fluoride, The Aging
Factor, Chapter 9 [The Human Sacrifice])
at the other side
of the universe. The real question is,
how likely is any one
particular
cause? In point of fact, fluoride causes
more human cancer deaths,
and causes it
faster, than any other chemical.”
Dean
Burk, Chief Chemist Emeritus (U.S. National Cancer Institute)
To help
avoid fluoride toxicity
·
Take
adequate amounts of vitamins B6 and C.
Supplement with calcium and magnesium salts to help decrease fluoride
absorption from the stomach and assist in elimination. (this is for people who live in areas where
the water is fluoridated and where they may suspect fluoride toxicity - consult
a knowledgeable nutritionist and health care professional for advice in this
arena).
·
Maintain
good general and dental health with a whole food diet (varied vegetables
(lightly cooked or raw), fresh fruits and pulses. Limit sugar intake and processed foods.
·
In
areas where the water is fluoridated, install a water purification system that
removes fluoride (not all water filters remove fluoride – a specialized filter
needs to be used – do your homework when buying a filter)
·
Avoid
the following drugs which contain fluoride:
Prozac (fluoxetine), Rohypnol (flunitrazepam), Diflucan (fluconazole,
Flixonase or Flixotide (fluticasone), Stelazine (trifluoperazine, Fluanxol or
Depoxol (flupenthixol) or Floxapen (flucloxacillin).
·
Use fluoride-free toothpaste, like Tom’s, Tea Tree, Sarakan,
Natural Propolis, Weleda, Aloedent and others.
Avoid mouth rinses and dental
gel treatments.
·
Avoid fluoride supplements
In September 2000 the Department of Health
legislated regulations in respect of fluoridation of potable water in
Rand Water
does not consider fluoridation of water as the highest priority for
The Department of Health has
legislated regulation indicating that water service providers are obliged to
fluoridate water to a concentration level of up to 0,7mg F/l as of September
2002.
Lerato
Motsoeneng, scientific services specialist of Rand Water, said that Rand Water
and the Department of Water Affairs and Forestry were in talks about the
fluoridation issue
“Rand
Water will, one the go-ahead is given, set up a fluoridation plant at
Bloemendal. This will be used as
evaluation before it can be applied to other areas,” said Motsoeneng.
The South
African local government association said that the implementation of fluoride
would begin in “front-runner municipalities where the agreement of the council
has been obtained”.
(Extract
from the Roodepoort Record Oct 3, 2003)
Some questions that come to mind
are: Who are these front-runner
municipalities?
Is the government allowed to
fluoridate without getting the public’s agreement? Does this not go against our
constitution? Medicating people without
their knowledge must be breaking the law on some level?
Since when has the government become
so concerned about teeth when we have starving, homeless and jobless people in
our country
Impact of Water Fluoridation on the
Environment
To meet
the required standard of 0,7 ppm of fluoride (the ‘proposed’ amount to be put
into our water), Rand Water will dose 1
500 kg of fluoride per day into the drinking water. However, of the 1 500 kg per day only 9,8
kg will be used by consumers for drinking purposes. Considering other consumptive uses, it is
estimated that 1 000 kg of fluoride will find its way back into the
environment.
As water
is a scarce commodity in
If 0,5 mg
F/l is added to our water supply this would theoretically imply (during periods
of drought or the dry season) that the effluent concentrations will also
increase by 0,5mg F/l as fluorides are not appreciably removed through the
wastewater treatment process. This for
example could increase the average fluoride concentration in the effluent
emanating from a works near Alberton to approximately 0.9 mg F/l which is only
0,1 mg F/l less than receiving water quality criteria. This may start presenting a problem to both
the receiving streams and the downstream users if not managed with care.
From an
article written by Tony Carnie (CNN’s African Health/Medical Journalist of the
year 2000) it seems that the Pelindaba nuclear/chemical complex (set up by the
apartheid government in the 60’s to produce atomic bombs and enriched uranium
fuel), is set to become the major supplier of the hundreds of tons of fluoride
which will be needed to add to the drinking water. Pelchem is believed to be the only local
company able to supply enough fluoride for the nationwide water-dosing
campaign. Pelchem stands to boost annual
revenue of about R130 million by at least 10% if it corners the local water
fluoridation market.
Palchems
commercial manager Eddie Valkenbergh said that Pelchem’s fluoride would meet
American water works standards, and was a “purer” form of the chemical than
fertilizer or aluminium industry. But Dr
Hardy Limeback, former president of the Canadian Association for Dental
Research, says the Pelchem supplies could not be regarded as pharmaceutical
grade medicine. He has urged President
Mbeki to set up a fluoridation panel to review whether or not South Africans
are especially susceptible to the harmful effects of fluoride.
Anti-fluoride
information if forever being discredited or suppressed. The need for this by pro-fluoridationist
already makes one suspicious. If
fluoride is harmless why does the Dental Association need to get indemnity for
implementing it? Are people possibly
aware of the negative effects and need to protect themselves from future
lawsuits? Can we really assume that the
dental welfare of children is that important?
When powerful financial considerations are at work, it is difficult to
ascertain true motives.
Environmental
scientists in the
Dr David
Kennedy writes: “Last Year (1995) the municipalities around
As at
September 2004, the situation is still unclear.
Rand Water are still fighting legal battles against the implementation
of fluoride, and the government is still insistent that they have a mandate to
implement it. Carltonville has been
named as one of the forerunner municipalities that will be fluoridated.
In Conclusion:
Water is a
fundamental element of Life. We start
our journey to this realm in the watery world of the womb - it is a part of us
and we are a part of it.
My wish
for us at this crucial time on our Mother Earth is the ability to see things as
they truly are, and the consequent empowerment to choose how we stand in this society.
May we all
take this knowledge and do with it what serves the highest interest, whether it
be caring for the diseased, preventing the sixth extinction, working to shape
and inspire a new society or raising tomorrow in our children. Let us all choose wisely.
Please
forward this information.
References
What
Doctors don’t tell you, ‘Fluoride, damning new evidence’ (Volume 9 No 12)
Fluoride: The Aging Factor, Dr John Yiamouyiannis. Health Action Press
Earthlife
Africa Jhb: Fluoride Fact Sheet (
Health
Counter News: Forced Medication of the
Nation (Autumn 1997)
Yiamouyiannis,
J. ‘Water Fluoridation and Tooth Decay:
Results from the 1986-1987 National Survey of School Children’ Fluoride Vol. 23, No 2, April 1990.
Websites
worth visiting: www.nofluoride.co.za or www.fluoridealert.org (this has a good
section on
Much of
this information also comes from the work of the late Dr Frank Bertrand, Mrs E.
Lombard and Mrs S. Holloway who’s dedicated work did much to inform South
African’s of the dangers of water fluoridation.